A conventional loan usually costs less over time for borrowers with stronger credit and at least 5% down. An FHA loan usually fits borrowers with lower scores, thinner down payments, or higher debt-to-income ratios. The only way to know which applies to you is to price both side by side.
Duane Buziak, helping buyers find the right mortgage since 2014, built Free Mortgage Search by Duane Buziak as a free comparison tool backed by broker independence. Both loan types can be priced across hundreds of wholesale lenders instead of one bank’s shelf, and NoTouch Credit Pull (a soft-pull comparison) runs first, so shopping does not touch your score. The seven strategies below run in the order a buyer actually decides: sort yourself, compare real payments, plan the exit from mortgage insurance, check limits and property fit, test your debt ratio, plan your cash, then confirm with live pricing.
1. Sort Yourself by Credit Score and Down Payment First
Score and down payment decide which loan deserves your first quote request. Conventional pricing is tied closely to score and loan-to-value, so strong credit with 5% or more down tends to reward you. FHA pricing is less sensitive to score, which is why it often wins for thinner profiles. These are starting hypotheses, not verdicts.
Suppose, as an illustration, Buyer A has a 640 score and 3.5% saved, and Buyer B has a 740 score and 5% saved. Buyer A starts with FHA, since conventional pricing at 640 with a sliver of equity carries heavy mortgage insurance. Buyer B starts with conventional, where a 740 score earns far cheaper insurance. Both still get priced on both loans.
| Your profile | Likely first loan to price | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Score 500 to 579 | FHA | HUD allows FHA with 10% down in this range; conventional is rarely available |
| Score 580 to 639 | FHA, then conventional | FHA allows 3.5% down at 580 and above; conventional insurance is costly here |
| Score 640 to 699 | Both | Often close; the payment comparison decides |
| Score 700 and above, 5% or more down | Conventional, then FHA | Lower PMI and a removable insurance path usually win |
FHA minimums come from HUD; confirm the current tables before relying on them, since individual lenders can set stricter score floors.
- Check your score range, not a single number.
- Total the down payment you can actually use, including gifts.
- Set a target price and find your row in the table.
- Price both loans anyway.
The common mistake is treating a minimum score as a promise of approval or good pricing. It only opens the door. Measure success by ending with one or two loan types worth pricing and the minimum down payment for each confirmed.
2. Compare the Full Monthly Payment, Not Just the Interest Rate
A lower note rate does not mean a lower payment. FHA adds an upfront mortgage insurance premium (1.75% of the base loan, usually financed) plus annual MIP. Conventional adds monthly PMI, priced by score and down payment. Only the all-in payment and the APR make two quotes comparable.
Take a $350,000 home, with these assumptions labelled as illustrations, not offers: 30-year terms, an FHA rate of 6.00%, a conventional rate of 6.25%, a 0.50% annual PMI rate, and $650 a month for taxes and insurance on both.
- FHA: 3.5% down is $12,250, so the base loan is $337,750. Upfront MIP of 1.75% is $5,910.63, making the financed loan $343,660.63. Principal and interest is about $2,060.42, annual MIP of 0.55% adds about $154.80 a month, and taxes and insurance add $650. Total: about $2,865.22.
- Conventional: 5% down is $17,500, so the loan is $332,500. Principal and interest is about $2,047.26, PMI adds about $138.54, and taxes and insurance add $650. Total: about $2,835.80.
The FHA loan has the lower rate yet costs about $29.42 more per month, while needing $5,250 less cash down. Which matters more depends on your savings, which is the point of comparing.
- Request quotes for both loans at the same price and the same lock period.
- Total principal, interest, MI, taxes, and insurance for each.
- Compare the APR on each Loan Estimate.
The mistake is choosing the lower note rate while ignoring MI and APR. Measure the total monthly payment gap and the APR gap between the two quotes. All figures here are estimates, and your actual APR depends on your full scenario.
3. Price the Mortgage Insurance Exit Plan
Many buyers assume FHA mortgage insurance drops off at 80% equity like PMI. It does not. Under current HUD rules, FHA MIP on a loan with less than 10% down generally lasts the life of the loan, and with 10% or more down it lasts 11 years. Conventional PMI can be requested for cancellation once your balance reaches 80% of the home’s original value and must end automatically at 78% of the original schedule, under the Homeowners Protection Act, which the CFPB explains. Verify the current HUD tables before you decide.
Consider an illustration: an owner plans to stay 10 years. With conventional financing, PMI ends once equity reaches the threshold, sooner if the home appreciates or extra principal is paid. With a low-down-payment FHA loan, MIP continues until the owner refinances. Suppose that refinance costs $6,000 and removes $150 a month in MIP: the break-even is 40 months, and that cost belongs in the FHA column.
- Estimate how long you will really keep the home.
- Project your balance and equity year by year, with and without appreciation.
- Ask for the MI cancellation or refinance path in writing for each loan.
One caution runs the other way: PMI is not permanent, but it is not automatic on your timeline either. You may need to request cancellation and show the home’s value has held. Measure total MI paid over your expected holding period for each loan, plus any refinance cost needed to end it.
4. Check Loan Limits and Property Fit Before You Fall in Love With a Home
Each program limits the loan amount and judges the property. A home can pass your budget and still fail the loan.
The FHFA sets conforming limits. As of November 2026, the one-unit baseline is $832,750, with a ceiling of $1,249,125 in the highest-cost counties. Limits vary by county, and FHFA typically announces the following year’s figures late in the year, so recheck. FHA limits are set by HUD as a share of the conforming baseline, with a floor in low-cost counties and the same ceiling in high-cost ones.
As an illustration, a fixer-upper with peeling paint and a failing roof may struggle under FHA minimum property requirements, because the appraiser must flag safety and soundness issues. A purchase in a high-cost county above the baseline may need a high-balance conventional structure. Condos add another layer: FHA requires project approval, and conventional loans follow project standards in the Fannie Mae Selling Guide.
- Look up your county’s conforming and FHA limits.
- Confirm property type and how you will occupy it.
- For condos, ask whether the project is approved for each program.
- Ask about repair or condition issues before making an offer.
The mistake is quoting a national limit without checking the county. Measure it this way: your loan amount sits under the applicable limit, and property eligibility is confirmed under each program before you write an offer.
5. Use Debt-to-Income Flexibility Deliberately
FHA generally allows higher debt-to-income ratios than conventional, particularly with automated approval and compensating factors. Conventional guidelines commonly sit around 45%, stretching toward 50% with strong credit and reserves. Exact ceilings depend on the automated findings, so treat them as ranges. The flexibility is useful, but being allowed to borrow it is not a reason to.
Here is worked math, as an illustration. Gross income is $8,000 a month. Debts are a $450 car payment, a $250 student loan, and $100 in card minimums, totaling $800. Using the housing payments from Strategy 2:
- FHA: ($800 + $2,865.22) divided by $8,000 is about 45.8%.
- Conventional: ($800 + $2,835.80) divided by $8,000 is about 45.4%.
Now suppose the $100 card is paid off before applying. Debts drop to $700, giving about 44.6% for FHA and 44.2% for conventional. A small payoff moves both loans under a common conventional threshold.
- List every monthly debt that appears on your credit report.
- Calculate DTI at each quoted payment.
- Test paying off one small debt and recalculate.
The common mistake is maxing out DTI because the program permits it. A 50% ratio leaves little room for repairs, childcare, or a lean month. Measure two things: the DTI percentage for each loan and the dollars left each month after housing costs. If the leftover figure makes you uneasy, a smaller price is a better fix than a looser guideline.
6. Plan Closing Costs, Gifts, and Seller Credits Around Each Loan’s Rules
Cash to close often decides a purchase more than the rate does, and each loan caps what the seller can contribute. Conventional seller concessions depend on your down payment: with less than 10% down, the cap is 3% of the price. FHA allows up to 6%. Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide sets the conventional caps, and HUD sets FHA’s.
On a $350,000 purchase, as an illustration, a 3% conventional cap is $10,500, while a 6% FHA cap is $21,000. A buyer short on cash could find the FHA cap makes the deal workable, and a buyer who negotiates no-out-of-pocket closing options needs to confirm each loan’s cap covers it.
Gift funds follow their own documentation rules. Both programs generally accept gifts from eligible donors for the down payment, with a gift letter stating the money is not a loan.
- Ask for a Loan Estimate for each loan.
- Confirm the credit limit on each, based on your actual down payment.
- Document every gift with a letter and a paper trail before applying.
The mistake is treating credits as free. A seller who gives $10,000 may hold firm on price, and a lender credit usually comes with a higher rate. Compare the trade-off as a number. Measure estimated cash to close under each loan with credits applied, and note which loan leaves you with more reserves after closing.
7. Run Both Loans Side by Side Through a No-Hard-Pull Comparison
Everything before this is a hypothesis. Live pricing settles it. Duane Buziak, as a broker, can place your scenario with hundreds of wholesale lenders instead of one institution’s product list, and that matters most when you are comparing two different programs at once.
| Dimension | Independent broker | Single-lender shelf |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing sources | Hundreds of wholesale lenders compared for one scenario | One lender’s own pricing |
| Loan types | Conventional and FHA priced together, matched to the best-fitting wholesale lender | Whatever that lender offers and underwrites in-house |
| Credit check to compare | NoTouch Credit Pull soft pull first | Often a credit check at application |
| Switching if terms change | Re-shop across lenders without restarting | Start over elsewhere |
As an illustration, one search returns conventional and FHA options for the same price, down payment, and lock period. You then read the Loan Estimates line by line.
- Enter your scenario in Free Mortgage Search by Duane Buziak.
- Review the soft-pull results.
- Compare rate, APR, MI, credits, and lock terms.
- Dare to Compare: put any other offer you hold next to these, line by line.
Rates and payments in the tool are estimates, and the APR shown reflects fees and mortgage insurance, so read the two together. The mistakes here are comparing only one loan type and comparing quotes with different lock periods. Measure the APR gap and the total monthly payment gap across at least two like-for-like options.
Eight Questions Buyers Ask When Weighing Conventional Against FHA
Is a conventional loan cheaper than an FHA loan?
Often, for borrowers with stronger credit and at least 5% down, because PMI is cheaper and can end. It is not guaranteed, so compare full payments and APR.
Is an FHA loan only for first-time buyers?
No. FHA is open to repeat buyers too, provided the home is your primary residence and you meet the program’s requirements.
Is FHA always the cheaper option for lower credit scores?
No. FHA tends to fit lower scores better, but its upfront and annual premiums can outweigh a lower rate. Price both.
What is the minimum down payment for each?
FHA allows 3.5% with a qualifying score and 10% at lower scores, per HUD. Conventional often starts at 3% to 5%, depending on the program and lender.
Does PMI last forever?
No. Under the Homeowners Protection Act, you can request cancellation at 80% of the original value, and it ends automatically at 78% of the original schedule.
Does FHA mortgage insurance drop off at 80% equity?
Not automatically. With less than 10% down, FHA MIP generally stays for the loan’s life, unless you refinance.
Does comparing both loans hurt my credit?
Not through NoTouch Credit Pull, which compares using a soft pull. A hard pull happens only when you choose to move forward.
Why compare through a broker?
A broker prices your scenario across hundreds of wholesale lenders, so you see both programs from many sources rather than one lender’s product list.
Where to Start: Two Strategies First, Live Pricing Second
Do Strategy 1 and Strategy 2 first. They narrow the field and show real monthly payments within an afternoon. Then use Strategy 7 to confirm with live pricing through NoTouch Credit Pull. Treat Strategies 3 through 6 as tie-breakers: when two quotes land close together, the MI exit, property fit, DTI cushion, or cash-to-close plan usually settles it.
When you hold an offer from somewhere else, Duane Buziak invites you to Dare to Compare: put it beside the results and judge for yourself, with no pressure either way.
Your dream home is within reach. Start comparing personalized mortgage rates from trusted lenders today and discover the loan solution that fits your budget and goals. Compare rates now and take the first step toward securing your home with expert guidance every step of the way.





